Jump to content
Head Coach Openings 2024 ×
  • Current Donation Goals

    • Raised $2,716 of $3,600 target

What will the future be for the N.I.C.?


Recommended Posts

1 hour ago, BLACKGOLD2007 said:

Penn wont join the DAC, too much driving from week to week.  But, if you consider that driving with the possibility of the driving you will do with an independent schedule, maybe it is the second best fit.

I think this argument was suspect when the administration made it in 2002, and does not reflect the reality of Penn's scheduling across almost all of its sports today. Most programs already compete against a number of teams in the Region--both home and away year-to-year--as well as against schools in the SAC plus Carmel and others. The flexibility of days on which all other programs compete mitigates travel concerns even more. A move to the DAC would require a different arrangement for when JV and freshman football games are played, something that should be seen as a welcome and necessary change anyway. Freshman football on Thursdays and the odd the Monday here and there makes no sense.

1 hour ago, US31 said:

Penn to the NLC makes zero sense for the NLC or Penn.

Agreed, just another square peg in a round hole situation. To your point, the NLC would make for a marginal improvement, but that's only because the NIC is one of the most conceivably bad arrangements for Penn in the first place.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, US31 said:

Penn to the NLC does nothing for Penn on the big stage. 

Is it better than current NIC situation....yes. 

Is playing Northwood, Northridge, Goshen, & Concord preparing you to beat the best schools in the Region, FW, and Indy...emphatically No.

Go Indendent, and I'm sure with in a year or so you could schedule Mishawaka, Warsaw, Elkhart, and a couple DAC schools, along with your marquee matchups with Carmel, Cathedrawl, Brother Rice, etc.  It seems like you could get CG on a schedule too.

Penn to the NLC makes zero sense for the NLC or Penn.

You are right, my thought about the NLC idea was the NLC has amazing fan bases and it is super local.  The games are always packed, so the amount of money for door and parking would go up.  But, grand scheme of things no, the smaller competitive local teams do not help prep a bigger Penn for any situation in the playoffs. 

The DAC or going Independent are the two premium options.

But, even with going Independent, there have to be filler games...

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, PDB26 said:

I think this argument was suspect when the administration made it in 2002, and does not reflect the reality of Penn's scheduling across almost all of its sports today. Most programs already compete against a number of teams in the Region--both home and away year-to-year--as well as against schools in the SAC plus Carmel and others. The flexibility of days on which all other programs compete mitigates travel concerns even more. A move to the DAC would require a different arrangement for when JV and freshman football games are played, something that should be seen as a welcome and necessary change anyway. Freshman football on Thursdays and the odd the Monday here and there makes no sense.

I think that when each option is laid out for presentation, if remaining in a conference is Penn's goal, then the DAC is the way to go....With that being said, I would suggest only going into the DAC if they jump to 10 teams and onboard Elkhart with them.  This gives Penn the opportunity to get 5 conference games and 4 non again.  Penn's conference schedule will improve right away, and they can still look south, east or north for touch competition. 

If the DAC wont move on that, Independent all the way.  

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 5/15/2023 at 12:10 PM, US31 said:

Penn to the NLC does nothing for Penn on the big stage. 

Is it better than current NIC situation....yes. 

Is playing Northwood, Northridge, Goshen, & Concord preparing you to beat the best schools in the Region, FW, and Indy...emphatically No.

Go Indendent, and I'm sure with in a year or so you could schedule Mishawaka, Warsaw, Elkhart, and a couple DAC schools, along with your marquee matchups with Carmel, Cathedrawl, Brother Rice, etc.  It seems like you could get CG on a schedule too.

Penn to the NLC makes zero sense for the NLC or Penn.

I said this before in a past post, but I think there needs to be restructuring within the conferences to make everyone more or less happy. Here is my take on the whole situation. 

Penn, Mishawaka, New Prairie, Warsaw, Goshen, Concord, and Elkhart

Plymouth, Wawasee, Northridge, Northwood, Adams, Riley, Washington

Just my take, Penn going independent just increases driving. Restructuring the conferences is a better solution. You have 7 in the conference, allows you to schedule 3 non conference opponents. Is it a perfect solution? No. But it is a happy medium. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Trojan67 said:

I said this before in a past post, but I think there needs to be restructuring within the conferences to make everyone more or less happy. Here is my take on the whole situation. 

Penn, Mishawaka, New Prairie, Warsaw, Goshen, Concord, and Elkhart

Plymouth, Wawasee, Northridge, Northwood, Adams, Riley, Washington

Just my take, Penn going independent just increases driving. Restructuring the conferences is a better solution. You have 7 in the conference, allows you to schedule 3 non conference opponents. Is it a perfect solution? No. But it is a happy medium. 

Why should the NLC blow up their conference to help SB area schools????

This would be stupid for Ply/Waw/NR/NW.  Say bye bye to a large amount of your athletic gate, and quite a few of your JV/Frosh contests in a lot of sports.  Several MUCH smaller athletic programs want nothing to do with the SB schools for those exact reasons.  Why should 4A NLC schools want to hitch themselves to those SB schools????

You could argue that the NLC is holding back Warsaw, but they have a much better situation in the NLC than they would in a South Bend/Elkhart conference.  

  • Like 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Agreed, one of the biggest reasons why the 3 schools are leaving the NIC is money. Playing the South Bend schools has led to a dramatic drop in gate the last 7/8 years. Also, they don’t field JV and freshmen teams in a lot of sports as well. What sounds good in theory doesn’t hold up in the real world. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 hours ago, Trojan67 said:

I said this before in a past post, but I think there needs to be restructuring within the conferences to make everyone more or less happy. Here is my take on the whole situation. 

Penn, Mishawaka, New Prairie, Warsaw, Goshen, Concord, and Elkhart

Plymouth, Wawasee, Northridge, Northwood, Adams, Riley, Washington

Just my take, Penn going independent just increases driving. Restructuring the conferences is a better solution. You have 7 in the conference, allows you to schedule 3 non conference opponents. Is it a perfect solution? No. But it is a happy medium. 

Yeah that would be a pretty brutal conference for NP to be in and noway that administrators would be down for that when you consider all sports. I think people forget that NP doesn't even have 1000 students, they are on the smaller side of 4A schools as it is. just for comparison sake Northridge is still 4A but has 1410, New Prairie is at 985.

 

Penn: 3345

Elkhart: 3330

Warsaw: 2096

Goshen: 2015

Concrod: 1694

Mishawaka: 1603

New Prairie: 985

Edited by npcougar15
Link to comment
Share on other sites

15 hours ago, npcougar15 said:

Yeah that would be a pretty brutal conference for NP to be in and noway that administrators would be down for that when you consider all sports. I think people forget that NP doesn't even have 1000 students, they are on the smaller side of 4A schools as it is. just for comparison sake Northridge is still 4A but has 1410, New Prairie is at 985.

 

Penn: 3345

Elkhart: 3330

Warsaw: 2096

Goshen: 2015

Concrod: 1694

Mishawaka: 1603

New Prairie: 985

Wasn't New Prairie wanting the competition? Thought that was one of the main reasons why they went to the NIC? 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 5/18/2023 at 8:19 AM, US31 said:

Why should the NLC blow up their conference to help SB area schools????

This would be stupid for Ply/Waw/NR/NW.  Say bye bye to a large amount of your athletic gate, and quite a few of your JV/Frosh contests in a lot of sports.  Several MUCH smaller athletic programs want nothing to do with the SB schools for those exact reasons.  Why should 4A NLC schools want to hitch themselves to those SB schools????

You could argue that the NLC is holding back Warsaw, but they have a much better situation in the NLC than they would in a South Bend/Elkhart conference.  

So, if your mad about the NLC not wanting to blow things up, then does the NIC tell the SB schools that they have to go independent or find a new conference? Because that is what I think people are trying to say without saying it. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

31 minutes ago, Trojan67 said:

So, if your mad about the NLC not wanting to blow things up, then does the NIC tell the SB schools that they have to go independent or find a new conference? Because that is what I think people are trying to say without saying it. 

All I'm saying is that whatever problems exist with current NIC schools....those problems are not the current NLC schools' to solve.  

At no point am I "mad" about anything.  I'm just trying to point out the reality of how these decisions are made, and all of these schools should be welcome to make the best decisions for their own student athletes.  Sometimes those best interests are common to other schools...sometimes they aren't.  

Edited by US31
  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, Trojan67 said:

Wasn't New Prairie wanting the competition? Thought that was one of the main reasons why they went to the NIC? 

yes and no. NP outgrew the old NSC; when the NSC disassembled NP, Glenn, Bremen, Jimtown didn't have much of a choice other than landing in the NIC. Not ideal but it worked for the time being. It was pretty apparent that it was going to be a temporary conference affiliation for certain members and honestly lasted a little longer than I originally thought. The NIC is NOT the best fit for ANY of the old NSC schools and with Elkhart forming and Mishawaka leaving it's created a bigger gap between the big schools (Elkhart, Penn, Adams) and medium sized schools (NP, St. Joe, Marian, Riley, Washington, Jimtown).

 

Unfortunately, NP sits in "no mans land" when it comes to conference affiliation. You have the NCC that's just a little too far to west to be apart of (man would it be great to play Hobart, Lowell, Andrean for a conference title every season) and you have the NLC which would be way more realistic and doable to the east. 

 

I said it before and I'll say it again, but this is the most balanced/stable conference's the michiana schools could create:

Penn, Elkhart, Warsaw, Mishawaka, Goshen, Adams, Riley, Washington

Northridge, Northwood, New Prairie, Plymouth, Concord, St. Joe, Marian, Jimtown (or if CMA wants to play)

Bremen, Glenn, LaVille, Wawasee, Tippy Valley, Knox, Rochester, Fairfield

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, npcougar15 said:

yes and no. NP outgrew the old NSC; when the NSC disassembled NP, Glenn, Bremen, Jimtown didn't have much of a choice other than landing in the NIC. Not ideal but it worked for the time being. It was pretty apparent that it was going to be a temporary conference affiliation for certain members and honestly lasted a little longer than I originally thought. The NIC is NOT the best fit for ANY of the old NSC schools and with Elkhart forming and Mishawaka leaving it's created a bigger gap between the big schools (Elkhart, Penn, Adams) and medium sized schools (NP, St. Joe, Marian, Riley, Washington, Jimtown).

 

Unfortunately, NP sits in "no mans land" when it comes to conference affiliation. You have the NCC that's just a little too far to west to be apart of (man would it be great to play Hobart, Lowell, Andrean for a conference title every season) and you have the NLC which would be way more realistic and doable to the east. 

 

I said it before and I'll say it again, but this is the most balanced/stable conference's the michiana schools could create:

Penn, Elkhart, Warsaw, Mishawaka, Goshen, Adams, Riley, Washington

Northridge, Northwood, New Prairie, Plymouth, Concord, St. Joe, Marian, Jimtown (or if CMA wants to play)

Bremen, Glenn, LaVille, Wawasee, Tippy Valley, Knox, Rochester, Fairfield

On paper I think you’re correct. But gate receipts also need to be considered. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 hours ago, Trojan67 said:

So, if your mad about the NLC not wanting to blow things up, then does the NIC tell the SB schools that they have to go independent or find a new conference? Because that is what I think people are trying to say without saying it. 

I don't think you can include Adams in the group.  I feel that with their new AD and numerous good coaches, they will be able to compete  with the big boys in the future.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 5/19/2023 at 4:28 PM, npcougar15 said:

I said it before and I'll say it again, but this is the most balanced/stable conference's the michiana schools could create:

Penn, Elkhart, Warsaw, Mishawaka, Goshen, Adams, Riley, Washington

Northridge, Northwood, New Prairie, Plymouth, Concord, St. Joe, Marian, Jimtown (or if CMA wants to play)

Bremen, Glenn, LaVille, Wawasee, Tippy Valley, Knox, Rochester, Fairfield

Not that I think it would happen anyway, but if you flipped Northridge and Concord for Riley and Washington in this above scenario... I could MAYBE see it working. But like others have said, I do not believe the NLC is in any hurry to basically blow up it's current structure just to fix the disparities the NIC has. Like @US31 said - it's not up to the NLC to fix the NIC's problems. I would think as thing currently sit, the NLC is pretty happy/content currently.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 5/19/2023 at 10:01 AM, US31 said:

All I'm saying is that whatever problems exist with current NIC schools....those problems are not the current NLC schools' to solve.  

At no point am I "mad" about anything.  I'm just trying to point out the reality of how these decisions are made, and all of these schools should be welcome to make the best decisions for their own student athletes.  Sometimes those best interests are common to other schools...sometimes they aren't.  

Preach.  We just need to accept that the NIC is on it's very last peg leg to stand on.  At some point the three schools will either be conference-less or make a small conference with SB St. Joe and Marian.  Penn and Elkhart have got to be looking at all of their options.  

It is a touch situation all around, but the SBSC has almost brought this upon themselves with their poor performing schools across the board.  I feel for the kids that go there.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 5/19/2023 at 4:28 PM, npcougar15 said:

yes and no. NP outgrew the old NSC; when the NSC disassembled NP, Glenn, Bremen, Jimtown didn't have much of a choice other than landing in the NIC. Not ideal but it worked for the time being. It was pretty apparent that it was going to be a temporary conference affiliation for certain members and honestly lasted a little longer than I originally thought. The NIC is NOT the best fit for ANY of the old NSC schools and with Elkhart forming and Mishawaka leaving it's created a bigger gap between the big schools (Elkhart, Penn, Adams) and medium sized schools (NP, St. Joe, Marian, Riley, Washington, Jimtown).

 

Unfortunately, NP sits in "no mans land" when it comes to conference affiliation. You have the NCC that's just a little too far to west to be apart of (man would it be great to play Hobart, Lowell, Andrean for a conference title every season) and you have the NLC which would be way more realistic and doable to the east. 

 

I said it before and I'll say it again, but this is the most balanced/stable conference's the michiana schools could create:

Penn, Elkhart, Warsaw, Mishawaka, Goshen, Adams, Riley, Washington

Northridge, Northwood, New Prairie, Plymouth, Concord, St. Joe, Marian, Jimtown (or if CMA wants to play)

Bremen, Glenn, LaVille, Wawasee, Tippy Valley, Knox, Rochester, Fairfield

I hear you on what is best for local school affiliation, but Mishawaka ran from Penn once, they wont join a conference with them again.  

I think in all honesty, if the NIC dissolves, the SB schools and the catholic schools joining together might be the only option.  Penn going to the Duneland with either Elkhart or NP would be interesting.  However, I think the NLC would be dumb to not try to scoop up Elkhart.  They could even consider NP, but that is a long drive from Wawasee and Warsaw.  But, the fanatics of the NLC will drive.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The issue with long drives isn't fans or Varsity Football on Friday nights.....its kids spending 2.5 hours in a bus on a school night to play a JV Tennis Match and all the other sports that don't exclusively play on Friday night.  Commuting for football doesn't bother me at all......but go talk to the baseball coach that has to play a double header 80 minutes away and then teach the next day.  That burns out coaches and their families very quickly

  • Like 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...
On 4/17/2023 at 11:49 AM, US31 said:

Its not.  The fact that some of the NIC schools cannot field JV/Freshman teams in MANY sports is the primary factor. 

Why should Bremen, Jimtown, Glenn, etc stay in conference when half the kids in their programs constantly have their games/contests cancelled.  Seems like the only responsible thing to do for their student athletes.  The reality is, this change says less about the smaller NIC schools and MUCH more about some of the larger schools.

All conferences have different by-laws, but generally is a combination of the Principals & AD's.

Bremen or John Glenn do NOT have freshmen football to my knowledge and haven't had it in idk how long. I do agree that the larger schools are a bigger problem, but we know the only school that didn't have a JV is Clay and they won't exist here in a few months.  I do think that things will work out for the best for everyone.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

As it relates to Elkhart I dont see them going anywhere.  Not that the ideas above dont make sense, because they do, but Elkhart has so little investment now in sports that while they are big enrollment wise they have fallen so far in the past year sports wise that they simply wont be able to compete anywhere else.  They have massive issues arriving on time to games in the NIC due to bus driver shortages that they simply cannot play a schedule where travel is so far.  They have had varsity teams LATE to games multiple times the past couple of years.  The state of Elkhart sports is really bad and I think you will see that now show up on the football field this year.  What was once a rising star with all sorts of hope has been mismanaged to the point that when Football and Basketball 6a jobs come open that the applicant pool is limited to current staff and local retreads says it all.  They have no strength program, ancient weight rooms and top level athletes looking to transfer as opposed to being a destination for transfers just 2 years ago.  The only sport they have beaten up on the smaller schools in the NIC has been football and that wont last.  Elkhart needs the NIC.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, Johnsnow said:

As it relates to Elkhart I dont see them going anywhere.  Not that the ideas above dont make sense, because they do, but Elkhart has so little investment now in sports that while they are big enrollment wise they have fallen so far in the past year sports wise that they simply wont be able to compete anywhere else.  They have massive issues arriving on time to games in the NIC due to bus driver shortages that they simply cannot play a schedule where travel is so far.  They have had varsity teams LATE to games multiple times the past couple of years.  The state of Elkhart sports is really bad and I think you will see that now show up on the football field this year.  What was once a rising star with all sorts of hope has been mismanaged to the point that when Football and Basketball 6a jobs come open that the applicant pool is limited to current staff and local retreads says it all.  They have no strength program, ancient weight rooms and top level athletes looking to transfer as opposed to being a destination for transfers just 2 years ago.  The only sport they have beaten up on the smaller schools in the NIC has been football and that wont last.  Elkhart needs the NIC.

WHOA!  That is huge info. I didn't not see Elkhart in that light, but that is sad. Elkhart has the potential to be a strong school across all sports. I hope it gets fixed asap.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, Johnsnow said:

As it relates to Elkhart I dont see them going anywhere.  Not that the ideas above dont make sense, because they do, but Elkhart has so little investment now in sports that while they are big enrollment wise they have fallen so far in the past year sports wise that they simply wont be able to compete anywhere else.  They have massive issues arriving on time to games in the NIC due to bus driver shortages that they simply cannot play a schedule where travel is so far.  They have had varsity teams LATE to games multiple times the past couple of years.  The state of Elkhart sports is really bad and I think you will see that now show up on the football field this year.  What was once a rising star with all sorts of hope has been mismanaged to the point that when Football and Basketball 6a jobs come open that the applicant pool is limited to current staff and local retreads says it all.  They have no strength program, ancient weight rooms and top level athletes looking to transfer as opposed to being a destination for transfers just 2 years ago.  The only sport they have beaten up on the smaller schools in the NIC has been football and that wont last.  Elkhart needs the NIC.

Thanks for articulating what is going on in Elkhart. As an outsider I've mentioned that there isn't much hype/momentum surrounding the EHS program but had no idea why. It all makes sense now. Unfortunate Elkhart couldn't capitalize on their momentum they had 2-3 years ago when they first consolidated. They were one of the most intriguing stories in the state. Now it kind of looks like they will be another Michigan City post consolidation (aimed more towards how everyone thought MC would be a juggernaut (especially in basketball) but it actually created the reverse and killed MC sports). 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So, could Penn go independent in football and stay in the NIC?  It seems this whole idea of leaving centers around football.  If the NIC downsizes I am sure they may not want to lay Washington or Riley but they did pick up Hammond Morton which is a lateral move.  In 5 years or less I suspect SB will be down to 2 high schools with the way they are losing kids.  Penn would have Valpo and Mishawaka.  Carmel is replacing Cathedral and they could always get them back.  They may want to keep playing Adams.  They have Elkhart.  NP and SJ would I assume continue to play them  Marian may too.  Many parochial schools in Ohio, Michigan, Illinois, and KY are looking for games.  I think they could work this out.  Just a thought.  Other sports can schedule more teams outside of the NIC so I have not heard a cry that all sports need to move on.  The other key is does the DAC want to expand?  Will their member schools want it or like it like it is?

 

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 7/6/2023 at 4:06 PM, SB1987 said:

Bremen or John Glenn do NOT have freshmen football to my knowledge and haven't had it in idk how long. I do agree that the larger schools are a bigger problem, but we know the only school that didn't have a JV is Clay and they won't exist here in a few months.  I do think that things will work out for the best for everyone.

Again….my quote was referring to the many other sports that AREN’T football.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 7/8/2023 at 9:08 PM, ASJCPUMA said:

So, could Penn go independent in football and stay in the NIC?  It seems this whole idea of leaving centers around football.  If the NIC downsizes I am sure they may not want to lay Washington or Riley but they did pick up Hammond Morton which is a lateral move.  In 5 years or less I suspect SB will be down to 2 high schools with the way they are losing kids.  Penn would have Valpo and Mishawaka.  Carmel is replacing Cathedral and they could always get them back.  They may want to keep playing Adams.  They have Elkhart.  NP and SJ would I assume continue to play them  Marian may too.  Many parochial schools in Ohio, Michigan, Illinois, and KY are looking for games.  I think they could work this out.  Just a thought.  Other sports can schedule more teams outside of the NIC so I have not heard a cry that all sports need to move on.  The other key is does the DAC want to expand?  Will their member schools want it or like it like it is?

 

 

I think if Penn exits the NIC, it will be all programs. I don't think they will be allowed to be the Notre Dame of our area. But, I have been wrong many times before. Independence in football makes the most sense for what Penn wants/needs.  However, if the DAC can agree to balance the conference in accordance to distance traveled to away games and competitive balance that is a strong option for Penn. 

If I am AD at Penn, I would push for independence, because in most sports we will continue to play the northern schools anyways. Look at the basketball and the baseball/softball schedules. The boys and girls played teams from all over northern Indiana.  

Penn schedule that I would look for:

alternate the between two catholic schools locally, St. Joe and Marian are still rivals of Penn, no need to kill that off. - Game 5

alternate between the three remaining south bend schools.  - Game 2

Mishawaka - Game 9 (always)

Valpo - Game 1 (always)

Team from Michigan/Ohio - Game 3

Team from Ft. Wayne - Game 6

Team from Indy - Game 4

Elkhart - Game 8

Larger school from the DAC or Lafayette area. - Game 7

This current version of Penn might not go .500 but this would be how I would like to see the schedule play out. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...