This is a interesting concept.
I like the idea of more non conference games and playing some other teams from around the area.
If going by enrollment Brownstown and Salem would switch, like it or not.
OR there is this scenario where you could match up based off of Sagarin rating of past season.
MSC Gold (Brownstown 82, Paoli 136, Silver Creek 154, Charlestown 158, Springs Valley 171, Scottsburg, 196, NH 203)
MSC Silver ( Salem 241, WW 244, Eastern 248, Corydon 265, Madison 272, Mitchell 294, Crawford 304)