Footballking16

Not a winning combination against a team like Ben Davis. Here’s to keeping tonight competitive and hopefully (remaining) injury free, heard the latter is a big concern after camp.

🔥🔥🔥

He's not alluding to the same type of points system you're thinking about.

Well now you're starting to speak my language...

Because a lot more teams "fail" than succeed. How do you quantify failure with 6 classes? Every team who doesn't win a sectional moves down a class? How the hell does that work long term? #1 Ben Davis beats #2 Brownsburg opening round of sectionals Brownsburg moves down to 5A? Sounds ridiculous, I know.

Because of the success factor...

A school with 2500 kids doesn't belong in a tournament with a school with 400 kids. I'll leave it at that.

I am vehemently against a system of promotion and relegation based on results at the high school level. It isn't feasible.

I didn't say that. But using your "clearinghouse method" of counting enrollment, Tech would likely become a 3A or 4A school and Washington a 1A or 2A school. None of which matters because it doesn't magically make either a better football program. Tech would not win an Indy-area 3A or 4A sectional and same for Washington in 1A or 2A. See my post above

It's pretty straight forward.

So relegate Tech to 3A or 4A and Washington to 2A and 1A and neither team is still getting out of sectional regardless of what you do with the P/P's or the success factor.

Again, what is the relevance to the success factor here? Bumping the P/P's up a class via multiplier or success factor isn't going to magically make Tech or Washington become a better football programs. You literally don't know what you're talking about. I can't speak for the other P/P's but the only scholarship Cathedral offers is performance based on the placement test. Has nothing to do with athletics. https://www.gocathedral.com/admissions/tuition/meritscholarships And yes, Cathedral draws from who applies. You aren't getting in without applying, I'll assure you of that.

I think I pulled an old rule. 18-1 Minimum Course Enrollment and Grades for Participation To be eligible scholastically, students must have received passing grades and earned credit at the end of their last Grading Period in School in at least Seventy percent (70%) of the maximum number of full credit subjects that a student can take and must be currently Enrolled in at least Seventy percent (70%) of the maximum number of full credit subjects that a student can take. a. The preceding notwithstanding, a student must have been Enrolled in a minimum of Four (4) full credit courses during the last Grading Period, and must be Enrolled in a minimum of Four (4) full credit subjects (or the equivalent) during the current Grading Period, unless a Block Four schedule is used, and then the student’s Enrollment must be in a minimum of Three (3) full credit courses. b. If grades reported at an Eligibility Certification Date include both Grading Period grades and semester grades, then semester grades take precedence for eligibility purposes. c. A student may use up to Two (2) semesters of the state-required physical education course for eligibility purposes, with each semester’s course counting as One (1) full credit. d. Physical education credit earned by participation on an athletic team, may not count toward academic eligibility. e. Class periods must meet Indiana Department of Education standards. f. In the event a School establishes minimum academic requirements which are greater than the IHSAA academic requirements, the IHSAA will consider those higher academic requirements to constitute the IHSAA academic requirements at such School, and will require that a student at that School meet those greater academic requirements before that student is eligible scholastically under this rule.

Guessing most schools (and almost all publics) abide by the IHSAA clearinghouse pertaining to eligibility: Grades: (1) If you did not pass 6 subjects in your previous grading period, (2) if you are not currently passing 6 subjects – Study Hall Does NOT Count, (3) if you are not currently enrolled in at least 5 academic classes

Warren Central has the most on-paper talent in the state. Not sure what last year, especially early in the season, has to do with a preseason poll for the following year?

Noted, thanks.

Oh? Must have confused you with somebody else?

It isn't Earth shattering news. Do you then propose the IHSAA implement a multiplier to public schools that have a higher socio-economic demographic?

Who says everyone at a P/P is affluent?

The same reason why IU still lands top basketball recruits: it’s a known program.

I made a comment in a different thread about open enrollment hurting some P/P schools and got mocked for it, but it certainly holds true. Pre open-enrollment, you played for your local public school OR you ponied up and played at a private school. There were some instances where families got good at manipulating a friend or families address, but for the most part, the IHSAA sniffed it out. Township and County schools have been taking full advantage of this. There's a reason why a kid can play 3 years at Westfield and end up at Warren Central. There's a reason why Lawrence Township kids flock across county lines to Mt Vernon. There's a reason why IPS athletes have been gutted by the some of the schools you've mentioned.

What purpose does it serve to have Hammond Bishop Noll play up a class? They're as bad as any team in the state. The success factor does what it intends to do; bumps up successful programs and doesn't discriminate against school type. I would agree that a 3-4 year cycle makes more sense.

The "everywhere" isn't the advantage you think it is, especially in central Indiana with open enrollment. If anything it hurts a school like Cathedral.

I will assure you winning never gets old regardless if it's in your enrollment based classification, the classification above, or even two above. High school kids don't think like that. They'll play wherever you tell them to play.

Cathedral can compete in 6A, you won't get an argument from me there. But belonging in 6A permanently just so a few more public schools can win the 4A and 5A title? I have an issue with that, especially when the only requirement is beating two of North Central, Lawrence North, and Lawrence Central in back to back weeks. At the end of the day, Cathedral has 1000 students playing 2 classes up against schools 3-4x their enrollment. That has to count for something.