Is your crew a relatively "new" crew? Would the average "experience" of the top 3 members affect the vote/ranking?
There are a myriad of factors that weigh into the system that is in use, that are beyond just meetings/games.
As Bob said, "Control the things you can control, like meetings attendance, test scores, clinics, video review, etc. Let the other things take care of themselves." I have told numerous crews/indiviudals the same thing.... It's frustrating, but it can be educational as time goes forward to reflect on things that hadn't been considered as impactful...in the future.
Having said that...let's take any further convo to PM on this subject.