Hot take culture. It's wild. Look at these 2 guys from their rookie years:
Player A: 63.8 completion %, 3,725 passing yards, 27 TD's, 14 INT's
Player B: 52.8 completion %, 2,074 passing yards, 10 TD's, 12 INT's
No GM in the League would currently take Player A over Player B and it's been that way for years.