Numbers used in this analysis are based on 2022 unless noted.
That 60-student drop, cost the school roughly $840,000, assuming that they all came from the Deanery, in just a single year. Logically, that's just the start. A kid that you would deny in their freshman year, for whatever reason, likely doesn't apply again in his sophomore year or junior year or senior year. So any of those freshman that wouldn't be admitted would be around $64,000 lost over a four-year span. If only half of the kids that were "kept out" were freshman, you're talking about a loss of just under $2 million over a four-year period. All total, assuming you cut 60 and 30 were in the freshman admittance, you're talking about $2,280,000 for a single year cut of 60 students plus ongoing fallout. For a 1A title in football? I'm not seeing it. Mind you that this school won a 2A baseball title in the previous year and had a 2A boys soccer team that's won a dozen or so 2A sectionals in a row.
Then there's an even BIGGER issue. Providence draws 299 of its 328, over 90%, from some 13 of its parishes. How long do you think Catholic schools last when they are keeping their own parishioners from attending? If Providence spent even a couple of years artificially blocking parishioners from entering, they would likely not be seeing an uptick as they would have poisoned their own well.