Any of those four would be logical choices. Woodlan would probably have the best "small school" feel, but beggars can't be choosers.
Another, albeit not quite as attractive, option is Harding. No action Friday nights anymore at that school, so they wouldn't have to worry about working around the "real" home team's schedule. Little farther drive, but with Maplecrest going straight through to 930 it wouldn't be unreasonable. My father still lives on the outer edge of the SE side and he can make it to Georgetown Square, via Maplecrest, in what seems like no time at all.