2008 - Center Grove (86)
2009 - Evansville Reitz (77)
2010 - Fishers (42)
2011 - Carmel (8), Warren Central (24), Indianapolis Cathedral (50), Ben Davis (56)
2012 - Lawrence Central (31)
2013 - Warren Central (32), Center Grove (46), Carmel (83), Indianapolis Pike (97)
2014 - Ben Davis (38), Carmel (60), Warren Central (67)
2015 - Center Grove (50), Mishawaka Penn (100)
2016 - Warren Central (32), Center Grove (52)
2017 - Ben Davis (5)
2018 - Warren Central (12)
2019 - New Palestine (80)
2021 - Center Grove (11), Indianapolis Cathedral (31)
2022 - Center Grove (72)
2023 - Ben Davis (48), Center Grove (56). Brownsburg (74)
* - No poll in 2020 due to Covid.