Unfortunately, it is fair. Realistically we know neither Cincy nor BYU are top 4 teams. But, in the year of Covid, and considering bowl games are being cancelled right and left, why not go with 8 teams for this year only? Give them their shot. It would be fun to watch!
I mean, who would have thought IU would be in the position they are in? They could be in that top 8 in 2 weeks!