BTF

Carroll really only had one bad game this year..........Warsaw. Mostly surprising because they have a really good defense and should have been ready for "Bart ball" having beaten the Tigers the year before. They certainly looked like Snider and HSE's equals when they played them.

I really don't. Are we talking best team or dynasty. I thought the topic was dynasty. Let's take this to another thread.

If it was Kilroy's, then yes.

Rodney? Where are ya?

Why is that? From 2009 to 2012 Bishop Luers was 24-0 in the post season with only two games decided by less than 10 points. If that's not dominance, I'm not sure what is. Average margin of victory 26 points. Lafayette Central Catholic also went 24-0 during that same time period with the closest game being 10 points. Average margin of victory 36 points. Warren Central was also 24-0 during their run. Only two games decided by less than 7 points. Average margin of victory 34 points. Looks to me like Lafayette Central Catholic is the winner here.

I would argue that many programs could claim they were this or that away from winning a game. I could write a book on that topic regarding my favorite team. I put Center Grove up there with Ben Davis and Penn. I'm not sure what makes the Trojans better than the Giants and Kingsmen. Over all, in all classes, I think we have to look at the four in a row by Luers and LCC.

I know this is a 6A thread, but are we including the other classes? Luers and LCC won four consecutive. That has to trump Center Grove.

I don't think it has to be. You simply divide Indiana into 8 regions and have a representative from each area. I think that's the best we could ask for even though the northern most reps and the southern most reps probably know little about the other's area. I'll be honest. There's probably not a group of people more informed than those here on the Gridiron. I don't think you could trust a current coach or AD since their primary focus is their own program and who they are playing next week. I can't imagine they have much of a grip on who the Top 8 would be. I will give the media some credit. Many of them are regulars on this site, but don't necessarily post.

Harrison, Mississinewa, and Heritage Hills are opting out of this. If I'm the AD at those schools, no way am I setting my programs up for that slaughter.

College football is different because you have super conferences, whereas you don't in high school. There are over 350 football teams in the state of Indiana and I'm not sure there is once conference that has over 10 teams in it. That being said, including a team that finished 3rd in their own conference would bore me to tears. Do I think an 8 team tournament with Carroll instead of HSE is more interesting on a state wide level? Absolutely. But I honestly wouldn't see it coming down to that as I don't have either in the Top 8.

Luers from 2009-2012. Lafayette Central Catholic from 2009-2012. I think those are your next two. There's been several. I'm sure Ben Davis, Penn, Center Grove, Western Boone, Roncalli, Chatard, Cathedral, and Sheridan would love to be added to the conversation.

Yes, arguably the best dynasty Indiana high school football has seen.

It was a good showing for sure, anyone who was there could tell you. But damn, talk about some lucky bounces. Also, you won't convince anyone from Northeastern Indiana that Snider wasn't the best team in the state that year when Quale Lewis wasn't in crutches. All I'm saying is that there have been a couple of teams from the north that were competitive since 1996. And I get what you're saying, by and large, it's been highly lopsided.

I don't see the point in including a team that finished 3rd in their own conference. I'm not proclaiming Snider's better than HSE, just saying that the rule should be 'no more than two teams from the same conference.' I'd rather give an outlier like Snider a chance. I eliminated Merrillville and Penn based on their blowout losses in the regular season, for the record. Also for the record, the HSE/Carroll game was VERY evenly matched. The difference was two pick 6's for touchdowns. But that's part of the game, so kudos to HSE for being opportunistic.

The difference in 2004 was two lucky touchdowns, an unforced error, and a D1 running back sitting on the sidelines. Just sayin. But I get your point. Games are lopsided for the most part. Penn gave a good showing in 2015.

I still think Cathedral is disqualified with four losses, that would leave room for Snider, who would get the nod based on their head to head with Carroll. Furthermore, how in the hell is Brownsburg a #4 seed? I think if there were a committee, East Central drops down to #4. I think many on that committee are going to look at their schedule that is predominantly 3A and 4A schools. That has to be taken into consideration. Yes, I know the win over Moeller was good.

Warsaw beat Carroll, who I still maintain is one of the best 11 or 12 teams in the state. And they have that clock burning offense that can take any team off guard. So I'm not about to fault Northwood for that loss. I don't know much about Northridge, other than they beat North Side to open the season. At that point, North Side was healthy and their mojo was high. So that was a good win for Northridge. Like Leo, I think Northwood is hitting on all cylinders when it matters most. I don't seem them rolling over for East Central.

Nah, I believe Northwood will get it done.

You'd have to be blind, deaf, and dumb to not see the advantages suburbia has over their counterparts.

It's a new era for sure. For three decades they were top 8 annually. As suburbia grows, so does their prominence in athletics.

Dwenger 1990 takes it.

Using Snider, East Central, and Chatard as an example. I'm sure all three of those programs and their fans would chomp at the bit to have that opportunity. But think of the financial ramifications. Bowing out in Round 1 or collecting gate money for four more games. It's no fun to think of it that way, but I think it's the unfortunate reality. I will say, that as a fan, I'd love to see a mandatory format like that.

I'm looking forward to this game. I left Luers for dead after the first two weeks of the season.

1. I keep giving kudos who throw their rankings out there, and I mean that. With over three hundred and fifty teams, I just find it hard to accurately come up with a Top 25. I enjoy Temp's Top 25 and appreciate the time and effort he puts into it. 2. Again, you're speculating. There's no way you can say that Crown Point isn't as good as Cathedral and Center Grove. You're letting prior year's results skew your opinions. 3. I'll take that one back, I don't really think your stupid. I appreciate your passion for high school football even though we disagree. I just think you put too much conviction in your opinions, stating them like they're facts. I always try to remember that we're all here for the same reason. We're all passionate about high school football. It's not a very large group. Most people would rather support money grubbing institutions like the NCAA and the NFL. So kudos to all who are here. But lets continue to debate and get on one another's nerves, it would be a boring forum otherwise.

Thanks for the information. I think we can all appreciate why Arizona went to that format. In my opinion, the only teams that would accept are 6A teams, they have nothing to lose. For levels 1A through 5A, I think financial matters come into play. For the record, as a fan, I would LOVE to watch this play out. I just don't see anyone lower than 6A jumping on board.