Actually yes, a 16 team tournament with 16 good teams would be much more fun. You certainly wouldn't have to deal with 60+ point sectional championships(New Pal v Anderson last year). But I guess you'd prefer just a few more regular season games and no tournament. I mean why would we want the season shortened and have games "taken away from kids" just because they lost. And to address your other point, qualifications would not be based solely on W-L records. Strength of schedule matters.