Bobref

Not this year. I’d imagine there will be some discussion about this in the offseason, as we’ll have information from the several states that have experimented this year.

😅😂🤣 NBC certainly thinks so. That’s why they’ve televised every Notre Dame home game since 1991.

First, let’s find out if anyone actually got sick as a result. Just like in officiating: “No harm, no foul.”

Sounds to me like perhaps you haven’t quite thought this through all the way. The SF already doesn’t have much meaning to 90% of the schools in the state in any practical sense ... since they will never be “successful” enough to have it affect them. It affects only those that have shown they can consistently punch above their weight class. Unfortunately, as presently constructed, it defines “consistently” far too broadly. But if tweaked to really affect only consistently successful programs, instead of also the aberrational class that a particular school might have once in a blue moon, it will work as intended.

Yes, I observe and evaluate crews for the IHSAA.

I’m going to be at Valpo Friday night observing the officiating crew. Would love to touch base with some GID folks who are going to be there.

Not necessarily. There are several ways the officials can handle a situation like that which would have prevented the defense from illegally consuming time.

Legitimate question, but what’s your alternative proposal? If it involves changing from a 2 to 4 year cycle, I’m pretty sur3 that has been fully explored in previous threads, and there’s nearly universal agreement that if you’re going to have a success factor system, a 2 yr. cycle is too short.

I disagree. I think the winner will be the team that gives up fewer points. 😅🤣😂

About what?

That is correct.

Just part of @southend’s continuing whinefest about P/Ps. Pay him no mind.

Not just a terrific official, but also a social psychologist! https://www.simplypsychology.org/maslow.html

There are a number of “potential “ benefits. As always, some schools take advantage, and some don’t. Speaking in general: Not as many kids have after school or weekend jobs that detract from their ability to be involved in extracurriculars. Kids can afford to go to clinics and camps in the off season. The schools can afford to pay more and better coaches, and there’s not as much coaching turnover. Don’t discount the advantages of better nutrition and more stable family situations. Ditto for facilities and equipment, which you seem to dismiss.

This is the kind of whiny sour grapes that is very uncharacteristic of a classy program like Lewis Cass.

I think elimination of any foul that is even tangentially safety-related is unlikely in the current “risk-minimization “ climate.

If anyone is actually interested in what the rules have to say on this subject: “Fighting is any attempt by a player or nonplayer to strike or engage a player or nonplayer in a combative manner unrelated to football. Such acts include, but are not ­limited to, attempts to strike an opponent(s) with the arm(s), hand(s), leg(s) or foot (feet), whether or not there is contact.” “PENALTY: Arts. 1, 2, 3j – Fighting, intentionally contacting a game official, striking, kicking or kneeing – (S38-47) – 15 yards and disqualification.” (emphasis supplied)

Any time the penalty is accepted for a live ball foul, other than an unsportsmanlike or nonplayer foul, the down is replayed unless the enforcement results in a 1st down, or the foul carries a penalty that includes either loss of down or an automatic first down.

Assuming the facemask foul occurred after the reception, it’s 1st and 2. The 5 yd. penalty is enforced from the end of the run and the down is replayed. If the facemask occurred before the catch, if accepted it’s enforced from the previous spot and the down is replayed, so it would be 1st and 5.

I am not prepared to second guess the people on the field on the basis of that very brief, less than optimal angle, video clip.

He took a swing, which is ejection-worthy in itself, whether it connects or not.

You have got to feel for Tua. A hip dislocation is not just a season-ender. It’s potentially a career-ender. Even if the imaging does not show a fracture, the concern is that the dislocation compromises the blood supply to the head of the femur. If that happens, the articular cartilage dies and you have a condition called “avascular necrosis.” That’s what ended Bo Jackson’s career. This will absolutely affect his draft status.

A couple of seasons ago my Ohio alma mater, St. Edward, traveled to Indy to play Cathedral. @PHJIrish invited my wife and I to join the Cathedral tailgate. I have never seen such great hospitality, respect, and sportsmanship from a collection of high school football fans. They are truly what high school football is all about.

I wouldn’t call it “hate.” At bottom, it’s grounded in “envy.”

I was at the game tonight, on the sideline, and have personal knowledge concerning the “bad” call on the L-Burg pass that was called out of bounds. Discussed it with the crew after the game. Here’s the skinny: it was, in fact, the wrong call. The receiver did have the ball with a foot in bounds. But ... The right call wouldn’t have helped the Tigers, because the receiver stepped on the sideline while running his route, just before the catch. The correct call should have been a foul on L-Burg for illegal participation. A 15 yd. penalty from the previous spot and replay the down. Make of that what you will.