Historically, these are the top 5 in all-time wins in Indiana:
1. Cathedral 774
2. Evansville Reitz 725
3. Sheridan 704
4. West Lafayette. 677
5. (tie) Linton-Stockton 666; Mishawaka 666
The next 10: 6. Hobart 654; 7. Culver Academy 650; 8. Elkhart Central (Elkhart) 648; 9. Bloomington South 647; 10. Hammond (Hammond Central) 633; 11. Rensselaer 620; 12. Carmel 614; 13. Lafayette Jefferson 607; 14. Evansville Memorial 604
Doesn't mean a lot as far as the top programs now, but interesting to see some schools on this list are still doing very well.